a close-up of a hand on a keyboard

What NOT to Say to Insurance Adjusters After a Florida Car Accident

Florida Uber/Lyft Crash Attorney

The adjuster who calls a day or two after your accident is usually recording the conversation. Anything you say can be used later to argue that you caused the accident or weren’t really injured. In Florida, this argument can now completely wipe out a claim.

Why One Sentence Can Cost You the Whole Claim

Florida switched to a modified comparative fault rule in 2023. Under Section 768.81(6) of the Florida Statutes, if an injured person is found to be more than 50% at fault for their own injury, they recover nothing. If they are found to be 50% or less at fault, the award is reduced by their share of the blame.

That threshold changes how adjusters work. Every percentage point they can shift onto you matters, and your own words are the cheapest evidence they will ever collect.

The clock is running too. Most claims for negligence must be filed within two years under section 95.11(5)(a), and a lengthy, friendly back-and-forth with the insurer does not pause it.

Statements That Damage Florida Accident Claims

Some of these responses may seem like simple politeness, which is why they can slip out without thinking. However, it’s important to be aware of how they may be interpreted by the other party.

  • “I’m sorry” – This may be intended as sympathy, but it can be seen as an admission of fault.
  • “I’m fine” or “I’m not hurt” – Adrenaline can mask pain, and injuries to the neck, back, and head often show up later. It’s better to be honest about your current state.
  • Guesses about speed, distance, or timing – If you don’t have information, it’s best to say so. “I didn’t see them” is a common phrase that gets quoted back often.
  • Anything about your phone, schedule, or why you were in a hurry – It’s okay to explain your situation, but avoid giving too much information.
  • Your full medical history – Don’t share everything at once. Questions about old injuries can be used to blame your current pain on a pre-existing condition.

You Don’t Owe the Other Driver’s Insurer a Recorded Statement

The other driver’s insurance company works for the other driver. Florida law doesn’t require you to give that company a recorded statement. Politely declining is normal.

Your own insurer is different. Your policy almost certainly includes a duty to cooperate, and for personal injury protection (PIP) benefits, section 627.736(6)(g) makes submitting to an examination under oath a condition of being paid when the insurer requests one. The statute limits questioning to relevant information. It is still sworn testimony, so talk to a lawyer before you sit for it.

What You Tell Police Is Treated Differently

Florida protects statements you make to an officer so that the officer can complete a crash report. Under Section 316.066 (4), those statements and the report itself cannot be used as evidence in a civil or criminal trial, with narrow exceptions.

No similar protection covers a phone call with an adjuster. A recorded statement can be used against you.

PIP Still Applies in 2026, and So Does the 14-Day Rule

You may have read online that Florida ended no-fault insurance this year. However, it didn’t happen. The 2026 repeal bill, Senate Bill 522, died in committee on March 13, 2026, and its House companion also died the same day.

So, PIP still pays for your medical care first, and section 627.736(1)(a) of the same PIP statute still requires initial treatment within 14 days of the accident. Waiting to see if the pain fades and telling the adjuster about it can cost you these benefits. It also gives the insurer an easy argument that you were not really injured.

What You Can Safely Say

Keep it short and to the point:

  • Your name and contact information
  • The name of your insurance company and policy number
  • The date, time, and location of the accident
  • That your lawyer will follow up on the matter

Talk to Hutch Firm Before You Take the Next Call

Adjusters are trained to sound helpful. Their real job is to close your claim for as little as possible. Hutch Firm knows this playbook from the inside: its trial attorney has spent years at two large defense firms, in boardrooms and on calls where insurers plan to shrink injury claims.

You have one claim and one chance to make it right. Hutch Firm handles evidence, negotiations, medical proof, and, if necessary, a trial, without fees or costs, until the firm wins. If an adjuster has already contacted you, or you have already said more than you intended to, contact Hutch Firm today before speaking with the insurance company again.